Affiliates
image
image
image
image
---------------------
image
Navigation :: The Cut Throats
FAQ :: Search :: Memberlist :: Usergroups :: Register :: Profile :: Log in to check your private messages :: Log in
Log in
Username:    Password:      Log me on automatically each visit    
Aliens: Colonial Marines

 
Post new topic   Reply to topic    The Cut Throats Forum Index -> Aladdin's Castle
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
Vlad Piranha
Dictator-Elect
Dictator-Elect


Joined: 15 Jul 2005
Location: Sector C Test Labs.
PostPosted: Wed Feb 13, 2013 10:15 am 
Post subject: Aliens: Colonial Marines
Top Reply with quote

Scratch another game off of the list of famous vaporware titles. Like fellow vaporware icon Duke Nukem Forever, Aliens: Colonial Marines was not worth the wait. ACM seemed to be in development Hell for several years. Problems with Aliens games seems like some sort of tradition as EA's Playstation 2 title of the same name was canceled in 2002 and Rebellion's Aliens vs Predator from 2010 was a poorly planned and uninspired piece of junk. After nearly three decades of tries, Alien 3 for the Super Nintendo and Aliens vs Predator 2 for the PC were the only good games to take full advantage of the licensing and do something cool and memorable. Considering the content matter of Aliens, it seemed like a sure thing for a great video game. Once again, the ball has been dropped. What shocked me most was that Gearbox, an industry darling, was responsible for development. What I thought was the most reassuring thing about the title ended up being a black eye. The game isn't awful, but potential was definitely wasted here.

The plot is strongest in the first act when everything still feels new. As a marine sent to investigate the aftermath of the films Aliens and Alien 3 (with emphasis on the first of the two), you board the ship Sulaco and encounter the same horrors as the film characters. The creatures are bad enough, but Weyland-Yutani has also sent armed units to contain the situation and they aren't even remotely friendly. The only things you won't be shooting to survive are your squad mates.

As simple as this sounds, this still had great potential. What we get is a game that takes almost every single one of its ideas from previous games. HUD and art design seems lifted directly from AvP 2010 and the plot is the same as Aliens vs Predator 2, minus the predators. What results from all this is not a polished game with only the best elements remaining. The aliens' first appearance was piss poor and, as a whole, they ceased to be scary almost immediately. The motion tracker was more likely to get you killed in the campaign as you're better off looking for threats with your weapon ready than reading that cryptic piece of crap for help. Even Rebellion's slipshod 1999 AvP game got that part right. Worst of all was how badly the plot retconned the Alien Trilogy to (poorly) rationalize its own existence. Even Marvel comics would be disgusted. It was an act of either blind fan service or arrogance, I'm not sure which. The fact that this quasi-prequel is supposed to be canon is just hurtful. I guess Aliens has its own Phantom Menace now.

AI involvement is spotty. On the upside, your squad mates will never block your path or get you killed. They'll even take the point once in a while to guide you, provided you aren't getting yourself lost looking for weapon upgrades or accessories. This is classic Gearbox Software design a la Half Life: Opposing Force. Unfortunately, there is no real interaction or creativity with your squad like that game, so your mission is left very linear. Aliens always seem to have the same scripted plan of attack: go after the nearest bot until you're spotted and then kamikaze straight at you. Unlike Left 4 Dead, your bots can't be killed. This keeps missions from becoming difficult thanks to bad decision-making on their part, but it also removes a key element from L4D that added variety and suspense. Since there's no advantage to attacking bots, every single alien will try to kill you when given the chance. In every fight, it's your responsibility to kill everything. The bots will help you in their own feeble way, but even Barney from Half-Life was more useful and assertive.

The one part of the game that was stunning was the sound design. Everything else felt old and tired, but this element of the game was spot-on and impressive. Voice acting was decent and featured a couple original cast members. Every sound effect was movie authentic right down to the clicks of menu selection. The icing on the cake was the title screen's layout and sound effects, making it feel like a Weyland-Yutani computer terminal.

I have yet to try multiplayer and will do a review entirely for that very soon, since that's the reason to buy this game.

In closing, Aliens: Colonial Marines is not the disaster that many publications are making it out to be. I'm bored with most shooters these days, so this was just another day at the office, though I can see ACM's shortcomings. What hurt this game the most was how it mimicked previous Aliens games and other titles like Left 4 Dead and didn't save any room for something new or original. It wasn't particularly scary, exciting or interesting for a title this hyped up. Had this been made by a no-name company, there would be forgiveness, but Gearbox can do better than this. A triple-A title ending up like this is just a shame.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Vlad Piranha
Dictator-Elect
Dictator-Elect


Joined: 15 Jul 2005
Location: Sector C Test Labs.
PostPosted: Mon Feb 18, 2013 9:33 pm 
Post subject:
Top Reply with quote

Multiplayer Review

I gave multiplayer nearly a solid week of playtime to decide for myself what to say about it. I wanted to be sure that I addressed every major concern and had a fair view of the online experience.

As I'd hoped, the multiplayer features of A:CM rescue the game's appeal from the dismal campaign. It's pretty obvious that the single player campaign of this game was tacked onto what was, at its core, a multiplayer title. This is a strange and amusing about face from previous Aliens themed titles that offered multiplayer features built around the mechanics of the single player campaign. What I got was a fairly robust experience that had more depth than what the game's surface implied. (I didn't bother with the campaign in co-op. I hear it's the same damn thing as the single player experience. I'm not having seconds of that crap sandwich.)

Races

Marine: Oddly enough, new players who have worked through at least some of the campaign will begin with a Marine as their stronger class. Playing the game in any capacity, be it campaign or multiplayer, will gain you experience points that you'll spend on your weapons and their upgrades. The most welcome discovery for A:CM is that, unlike Aliens vs Predator 2010, there is no bad Marine weapon. They all have their uses that will suit one player over another depending on his or her playstyle and they can be customized via upgrades to further suit those needs or fill even more specific roles. Do you like close quarters combat and want to throw away accuracy in favor of an increased rate of fire? The SMG does that. Do you prefer a medium range weapon to help you put down a threat at a distance? What if it's a fast mover or you aren't a good shot? Take the M41A Pulse Rifle and upgrade it with the high capacity magazine and you'll check both of those boxes. The Battle Rifle can be given sniper capabilities with magnum rounds and a long range scope or it can be an all-purpose bullet hose with a laser sight and a threat-detecting 'smart scope'. Shotguns, Assault Rifles, Pulse Rifles, explosive rounds, this game has it all. If you need to put holes in a wall crawling monstrosity, there are a thousand ways to do it. The best part is that the campaign has hidden (but non-customizable) movie-themed weapons in it that have their own specific bonuses and are well worth the trouble of seeking out. I grabbed Hudson's Pulse Rifle from a supply room in the sewers and I've been on a rampage ever since.

Aliens: The Alien class selection of AvP2 has returned with glory! You can choose from the Warrior, the Spitter and the Lurker and each has its own play style and upgrades. The Warrior is your go-to killing machine. Attacks with its claws and tail are straightforward and you can buy upgrades to help you develop a fighting style with them to suit your needs. I prefer a flurry of quick blows and a circular tail whip to help me attack groups of Marines as quickly as possible, since they try their best to move in groups for survival. The Spitter launches acid over long distances with a pretty rapid cooldown. Using their innate Alien ability to climb walls and regenerate health, the Spitter can throw devastating amounts of damage down upon Marines while being a difficult target to pinpoint (hence the Marine's choice of sniper weapons). Don't make the mistake of thinking the Spitter isn't well suited to close range combat. They have your choice of melee attack for a secondary weapon and upgrades can make the class focus specifically on close range. You can sacrifice the long range capabilities of the normal acid spit wad to choose to spray acid mist. This is like being attacked with an acid shotgun and hurts every bit as much as that sounds. The most stylish class is definitely the Lurker. His primary attack is your choice of melee attack, but his true personality comes from his alternate attack: he makes a long distance pounce that, if it connects with an opponent, knocks him down and then proceeds to slash his victim to death with his claws. There is a chance to shoot the Lurker off of the Marine, but three quick slashes and the poor bastard dies, so he'd better hope he didn't wander too far from his allies to look for ammo. All Aliens slowly regenerate health and can climb walls to move from place to place in search of prey.

Game Modes

The game features four distinct game modes that offer different experiences. They all are played two rounds at a time to give each team a chance to play both races. Comparison of scores in one way or another determine the winning team. The modes are as follows:

Team Deathmatch: Fight the opposing team for a set amount of time. Your kills are added to your team's total. At the end of the time limit, your team achieves a score based upon kill total. Deaths, of course, feed points to the enemy and the scores of both rounds will be added together to form your final score. This dual play style to meet the total adds an interesting element of chaos to the mode. I've seen rounds where a team falters badly as one race only to rally and utterly rout the enemy once on the other side. This variety keeps rounds exciting from game to game as a player can compensate for a lack of experience as one race by playing to strengths with the other. I get my points as the Aliens and try as best I can to survive in order to keep what head start I've achieved.

Escape: Think Left 4 Dead on this one. So much of the game seemed to emulate L4D, but this is honestly the only part that reminds me of it and that's not a travesty. The Marines need to get from point A to point B in one piece. Along the way, they'll need to hold defensive lines as they wait for elevators and other delays. The goal of the Aliens is to simply kill them as quickly as possible. The distance both teams manage to cover before being overwhelmed is factored into their scores. Bonuses are awarded for to the Marines for each of their squad members to complete his mission in one piece. There is no penalty for dying in an aggressive effort to kill the humans, so xenos will want to be crazy aggressive when the opportunity arises and try for coordinated strikes.

Extermination: King of the Hill, essentially. Like Escape, kills and deaths are only relevant to pride. Objectives are the only way your team will acquire points and those are only gained by arming explosives as the Marine team to destroy clusters of alien eggs spread out around the map. To arm the explosives, you must stand in proximity to the charge that awaits your team's arrival. At least one marine must remain in the area until the weapon activates and any enemies in the zone will halt the countdown timer. Strategy revolves around whether to band together for survivability or disperse (and how widely) in order to hit more zones at once. Aliens will do their best to slaughter anyone they come across, especially in zones, since the Alien round has no other objective. The specific areas of combat make certain loadouts for the Aliens more viable than others, so players who love this kind of event will build their creatures to fight groups of Marines well. I've always liked the tail whip as a weapon, but being able to spin that thing in a circle in the middle of a capture party may save the round. I've killed an entire squad that way. It's an incredible feeling.

Survivor: As the name implies, the Marines must simply survive as long as possible while the clock ticks. The amount of time alive for each player factors into the score and both teams take their turn trying to gore the human team. When in doubt, the arenas have plenty of nice defensible areas for the Marines to try to fortify. Bear in mind that the Aliens have infinite lives and it's a shame that those dead ends don't have any place to pick up ammo...

Overview

Cons

To search for games, you need to use the game's matchmaking system. You may remember this pain in the ass from Aliens vs Predator 2010 since SEGA used it in that title as well. A:CM has the potential to become laggy to the point of being unplayable due to how the system chooses a player in the game lobby to host the game. If that player isn't up to the responsibility, you're screwed and need to go find a new game. Other players with horrid pings have the potential to drag everyone else down just by being present, as well. This game needs a better server selection method in the worst freaking way. Without a way to weed out problem players, users will put up with this crap for the forseeable future. You can, luckily, organize games around your friends list to get a really good game in.

Speaking of problem players, for reasons unknown, 'Push to Talk' is disabled by default in this game. Ignorance to this fact boils down to mic spammers for entire matches. For the longest time, in every match, I swear I had to listen to at least one player from Latin America watching TV at full volume while a fan blows on its highest setting. Because of its shoddy, bandwidth demanding construction, driving your teammates insane is the only thing in-game voice communication is good for. I barely get coherence out of it even when pings are good and players are pleasant. Ventrilo will be a close friend of A:CM players, mark my words.

When you do manage to find a great game, due to the timed and objective based rounds, you'll be in that game no longer than ten minutes before the game ends. The players from the game return to the lobby before a new round is launched, which leaves some potential to keep the good times rolling, but they almost always abandon ship, leaving you with a de facto new game anyway.

Gearbox chose a third person perspective for Aliens in order to make crawling on the walls more instinctive, but this design ironically watered it down. While in previous games, your ability to scamper along any surface was necessary for hiding, stalking, assaulting and escaping the enemy (and playing as the damn Alien), A:CM multiplayer has limited its major use to navigation. You can still descend upon an unwary Marine to tail whip him to death unexpectedly, but it's not the strategy it once was. On the upside, that was one of the many unbalanced and unfair strategies in AvP 2010 that were abused heavily, so it won't be missed. Also, you can't crawl on every surface, so if there's a cardboard box in your way when you try to climb a wall, the game starts freaking out. I don't have a more eloquent way to describe how it tries to figure out what the hell is going on in that scenario.

Lastly, the Marines get their gear from the campaign, but Aliens can only level via online play, putting them at a starting disadvantage. Weaponry is useable and selectable in at least some form while you can only get vital Alien attack styles through grinding and slaying. You'll need to play for a few hours before you'll achieve the level of lethality you deserve.

Pros

When this game is in full stride, it's pretty great. It's fun as hell to play once you get the necessary upgrades for your bugs. Once you upgrade their speed and find the attacks you like, they become the fearless killing machines you see on the movie screen. I praise Aliens vs Predator 2 often enough even outside of discussions like this one, so you can imagine that it casts quite a shadow. Amazingly, this game still offers a better melee combat experience for the bugs than that even that masterpiece could. Gone are the days where you simply maul guys until they drop. Stringing together a series of savage claw slashes into a head-removing uppercut is a thrill every goddamn time and looks cool as hell (without AvP 2010's disturbing levels of violence). The third person perspective only gives you more of an attachment to your chosen xeno class and helps you aim your attacks, so I welcome it.

As I stated, Marine weapons are all fun and unique. You'll be able to do some real damage from the start and be able to really compete if you played the campaign and found the unique movie weapons. Perhaps most satisfying at all is the return of the flamethrower. There are no problems with balance this time. It's not that Old Toasty isn't crazy awesome, which it is. You need to track down the weapon in the stage in traditional deathmatch fashion and only use that unless you're willing to toss it aside to return to your normal loadout. From there on, you'll typically either run it dry or be mobbed after the Aliens get sick of being fried. In this way, you'll only find one such weapon in the stage at a time; enough to be a great threat to the Aliens, but far from enough to ever stop them indefinitely, just like the movies. I have yet to use the entire canister of fuel before I go down, but I guarantee my portion of the map will smell awful before that ever happens. That's fun enough for me.

Leveling is still not terribly time consuming and you'll enjoy playing enough to get what you need without too much worry. It only gets better, so you won't be missing anything in the meantime.

Bottom Line

This game is made for multiplayer. If you threw together a LAN party or had 10 people who you could turn into an organized online event with Ventrilo to communicate, you could effectively eliminate all of my complaints about this game's multiplayer and turn it into a pretty good way to burn a Friday night. In any case, it's still a hell of a good time when the stars align. If patches come out for this guy to smooth out the wrinkles, it'll get the popularity that it still deserves.

This is not a $50 game. Once it's featured in a Steam sale or inevitably gets it's price cut to $30, then movie or genre fans should absolutely pick it up. If it ever features on Steam for $20, you'd be stupid to not get it regardless of what you expect. I hope like hell that I get the chance to play this with you guys sometime. I'll be playing the crap out of it until that day comes. It'll be glorious.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic    The Cut Throats Forum Index -> Aladdin's Castle All times are GMT - 5 Hours
Page 1 of 1

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB
Shoutbox
Messy Recipe:  deleted all the last couple years worth of bots & managed to preserve the two real people that have posted since then xD

so many DELETED spam posts now tho that I think I'll need to automate cleaning those moreso than i already have

Messy Recipe:  sry about the bots :( been busy & havent gotten round to doing the usual cleanup

need to prolly stick this behind cloudflare or something

Drunken Monkey:  doing well, been building a hobby ranch of my own, got married, no kids, only dogs, sheep and a horse

Comradekil:  so anyway, i wonder how everyone's lives all progressed.. who's in jail? who's grandparents now.. ha life
Drunken Monkey:  and yes....i do miss 1942 aswell, i honestly think it is what drove me to get a M1 garand in real live, and is still my most used rifle
Drunken Monkey:  bots are getting silly
Comradekil:  Sup dudes
Messy Recipe:  the BAR-1918 always felt so good in that game
Messy Recipe:  I miss vanilla 1942 as much as Pirates... need to see if the Origin version (or even original) still has anyone playing sometime
Stealth:  Hello all! Head to the lounge and post a memory!
Stealth:  I saw a BF1942 fraps video of a guy jumping out of a plane and RPG'd another plane. I immediately came here for nostalgia. Miss you all.
Messy Recipe:  I've not tried Sea of Thieves... kinda was bummed to learn its servers don't allow many simultaneous players. gimme 32v32 galleon fights
Messy Recipe:  oh gosh I really need to automate the spambot removal instead of making myself do it by hand don't I -.-
Drunken Monkey:  merry Christmas you lot
[BB]Piccolo:  Anybody playing Sea of Thieves?
[BB]Piccolo:  I'm amazed I actually still knew my login. We Black Buccaneers certainly had a special relationship with you Cut Throats. Nothing like a fierce rivalry to make the battlefield exciting, eh? :)

Username:
Password:
Auto-Login